Difference between revisions of "Potterybarning"

From FreekiWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m
m
Line 1: Line 1:
Potterybarning is a term derived from [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pottery_Barn_rule The Pottery Barn Rule] in American political jargon ("You break it, you bought it).  It is a social outcome where a soft transferrence of ownership/responsibility of a particular task from one individual occurs following a question or critisism by another.  It is mechanically related to expression of resentment or ad hominen attacks from a person whose idea is questioned or criticized.  An example: Person A "We should get a truck!" Person B "Well, how much will that cost?" Person A "Look, we've wanted this for a long time.  Do you want to find that out and let us know?"  Person B "(to self) I thought I was asking a question, not taking on a committment!" Person A (after long stunned pause by B) "I'm trying to empower you!"  This term (as applied to Free Geek) was coined by Luiz.
+
Potterybarning is a term derived from [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pottery_Barn_rule The Pottery Barn Rule] in American political jargon ("You break it, you bought it).  It is a social outcome where a soft transferrence of ownership/responsibility of a particular task from one individual occurs following a question or critisism by another. It occurs because the person being questioned views the questioning as a soft block of an idea or as an attack on their competenceInstances of emotional vestment by the original owner result in resentment or ad hominen attacks from the person whose idea is questioned or criticized.  An example: Person A "We should get a truck!" Person B "Well, how much will that cost?" Person A "Look, we've wanted this for a long time.  Do you want to find that out and let us know?"  Person B "(to self) I thought I was asking a question, not taking on a committment!" Person A (after long stunned pause by B) "I'm trying to empower you!"  This term (as applied to Free Geek) was coined by Luiz.  This page is part of his coping with this [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kobayashi_Maru Kobayahsi Maru].

Revision as of 13:19, 11 October 2007

Potterybarning is a term derived from The Pottery Barn Rule in American political jargon ("You break it, you bought it). It is a social outcome where a soft transferrence of ownership/responsibility of a particular task from one individual occurs following a question or critisism by another. It occurs because the person being questioned views the questioning as a soft block of an idea or as an attack on their competence. Instances of emotional vestment by the original owner result in resentment or ad hominen attacks from the person whose idea is questioned or criticized. An example: Person A "We should get a truck!" Person B "Well, how much will that cost?" Person A "Look, we've wanted this for a long time. Do you want to find that out and let us know?" Person B "(to self) I thought I was asking a question, not taking on a committment!" Person A (after long stunned pause by B) "I'm trying to empower you!" This term (as applied to Free Geek) was coined by Luiz. This page is part of his coping with this Kobayahsi Maru.